Click to call 602-254-8880 24/7 Click Here for Free Consultation

News Articles

No Charges Filed; Fire Victims Irate U.S. Attorney Says Evidence Supports Lost Woman

As Paul K Charlton, the US attorney for Arizona, prepared to announce that he was not going to file criminal charges in the catastrophic “Chediski” fire, Overgaard resident Steve Lillie entered the gymnasium toting a charred pine log.

“I had 12 acres I was building a resort on,” Lillie said, “and this is what’s left. … There’s no accountability. No remorse. Nothing.”

When Charlton took the microphone and said, “Our decision — my decision — is not to prosecute,” Lillie, 44, stood and hurled the burned log near the half-court line, where it crashed and broke in two. “And there’s my decision!” he yelled. “You want to take me? Go ahead. That’s my life right there.”

Lillie’s was the most radical reaction to news that no criminal charges will be brought against Valinda Jo Elliott, the stranded woman who set a signal fire that merged into the biggest fire in Arizona history.

Charlton told a crowd of about 300 at Mogollon High School that Elliott did not act with criminal intent and that there is no chance a jury would convict her of arson, given the facts. Charlton said investigators spent the past month interviewing witnesses, checking cellphone logs and following other leads to confirm every detail of the account.

If anything, Charlton said, the evidence supports defense claims that Elliott’s signal fire was necessary to alert rescuers and save her own life after being lost three days in the woods.

The decision infuriated White Mountain residents who were burned out by the last month’s “Rodeo-Chediski” fire, and Apaches concerned about unequal justice because charges were filed against a tribal member who set the Rodeo half of the blaze.

Tribe may arrest her

In Whiteriver, White Mountain Apache Tribal Chairman Dallas Massey Sr. said the tribe likely will issue an arrest warrant for Elliott, possibly as early as today.

“We have a number of violations here — arson, trespassing, not respecting a closure order and possibly violating some of our game and fish statutes,” Massey said. “Nothing that the U.S. Attorney decided to do has altered our aggressive pursuit of this matter.

“Even if they weren’t sure they would have gotten a conviction, it would have been a nice gesture to all affected to try.”

It was a sentiment shared by those who attended Charlton’s press conference.

As Lillie was handcuffed and hustled outside by Navajo County Sheriff’s deputies, most of the audience booed and yelled derisively. About half the crowd stormed out of the gym in protest, unwilling to hear Charlton’s explanation.

“You take him away, but you won’t do anything to this woman who ruined so many of our lives,” yelled Carla Emmert of Overgaard.

“This is just ridiculous,” agreed Dan Caivano of Heber, chiding the deputies who arrested Lillie for disorderly conduct. “Who’s going to follow any laws around here if you’re not doing anything to her?”

Elliott was not available for comment Thursday. She and attorney David Michael Cantor flew to New York City to appear today on CBS’ The Early Show, which airs at 7 a.m. on Channel 5 (KPHO), the station whose helicopter crew rescued her.

“When Miss Elliott started the fire, she did what any reasonable person would do after being stranded for three days with no food or water,” her attorney said. “She feels bad for people who lost their homes.”

In Heber, Charlton told the crowd that investigators had confirmed every detail in the misadventures of Elliott and her employer, Ransford Olmsted, who got lost while driving to Young on a business trip.

On June 18, he said, they took a series of wrong turns and wound up out of gas on backroads in a closed section of the Indian reservation.

After spending a night together in Olmsted’s truck, Elliott climbed Chediski Peak in hopes that she could get a signal on her cellphone to call for help. Wearing flip-flops and a tank top, she became lost while trying to return to the truck and spent a night alone, sleeping on a flat rock after being frightened by a bear. The next day, Elliott set a fire to attract a nearby news helicopter, which was in the area to cover the Rodeo fire, which had been set a day earlier.

When Elliott was rescued, Charlton said, she expressed concern about the signal blaze, and was told by the helicopter crew that it would be extinguished. Charlton then showed a photograph taken two hours after the fire was set, showing that it smoldered meekly in a sparsely forested area. “A reasonable person could have expected this fire to remain contained,” he said.

But it soon exploded and joined the Rodeo fire to burn more than 468,000 acres and destroy 491 structures. The blaze cost more than $43 million to fight and forced the evacuation of about 30,000 people.

Helen Grand of Pinecrest Estates, one of nearly 200 people who lost homes in the Overgaard subdivision, was critical of Charlton.

“He does nothing, she walks away scot-free and our insurance company won’t have anything to do with us,” Grand said. “Boy, life is just wonderful these days.”

Grand’s husband, Ray, said Elliott “should be brought up here by the police and have her nose stuck in every pile of ashes she’s responsible for.”

Elliott’s fate sparked intense political debate because Leonard Gregg, 29, an Apache firefighter from Cibecue, has been indicted for setting the Rodeo fire to get work. Gregg, who made a public apology, is in Maricopa County Jail.

Some Native Americans have speculated that race was a motivating factor behind Gregg’s arrest.

Debora Euler-Ajayi, Gregg’s attorney, said: “This decision allows the tribe to bear the full brunt of the fire without acknowledging their loss. It gives them an example of White man’s justice. I expect the tribal reaction to be very strong and very unhappy.”

Federal officials have denied racism charges.Charlton met with tribal officials as well as community leaders from the Heber-Show Low area on Thursday before making the public announcement. But his private sessions apparently did not calm the passions.

“I still can’t believe that they’re doing nothing about her and a member of my tribe is looking at 10 years and a $500,000 fine,” said Waynella Collelay, who was selling tacos and frybread in Whiteriver Thursday afternoon. Boss defends Elliott Olmsted, a New River businessman who took Elliott on the ill-fated trip, expressed sympathy for the fire victims. However, he defended Elliott and praised the government for dropping the case.

“They made the right decision because we were out there innocent and we were lost and facing our lives,” he said.

But some residents don’t see it that way. They complained bitterly that Elliott never expressed sorrow, and now appears to be capitalizing on her fame with a TV appearance.

Mell Epps, the fire chief in Heber-Overgaard, said many believe Elliott should be brought to trial so there is closure, but he disagrees.

“I think we have a majority of survivors here, and I think they’re going to rally and be just fine,” he said. “We took a hit. We got wounded, but not killed.”

Bikers Descend on Cave Creek

How many motorcyclists hell-bent on keeping their good name can you cram into a one-road community of 3,600 residents?

Inspired by accusations that Cave Creek is prejudiced against motorcyclists, thousands of the leather lovers are expected to descend on Cave Creek this weekend for the unsanctioned, nine-day Cave Creek Main Street Rally.

Last month town officials denied promoters a permit over concerns about noise and traffic congestion. Then on Friday, in a last-ditch effort to kill the rally, a judge granted Cave Creek an injunction to prevent promoters from advertising the event.

Cave Creek resident and promoter Jim Zorn called the injunction “ridiculous” since everyone knew about the rally anyway. Her attorneys have contended that a permit was never needed since most of the events would be held at local restaurants.

“Bottom line, merchants will be open and things will go on as planned,” said [Cantor Law Group] attorney.

Cave Creek Town Manager Usama Abujbara has repeatedly said Cave Creek is not prejudiced against motorcyclists and the town would have been more agreeable to the event if it hadn’t been scheduled the same weekend as tonight’s Cave Creek Jazz Festival, which draws 15,000.

“This town can accommodate just so many people at once,” Cave Creek Mayor Vincent Francia said. “If 100,000 bikers show up there will be trouble.”

Maricopa County Sheriff’s Lt. Dave Trombi said 30 to 35 extra deputies will be present during peak periods along with mounted units, canines and motor units. Volunteer Sheriff’s Posse members will direct traffic along the mile and a half section of Cave Creek Road that snakes through town. Trombi said he’s not expecting trouble but will have the sheriff’s command post and air unit available if needed.

Zorn said she has received threatening e-mail from people suggesting she move away. Zorn said if trouble does develop the town is to blame for making this inaugural event an issue originally.

“This town has created something bigger than any of us could have dreamed of,” Zorn said.

According to Zorn, original projections for the event would have brought 100 more people a day to the town. “But now we have no idea what to expect,” Zorn said. “Bikers all over the world have told us they’re coming to Cave Creek. It’s a personal mission.”

One of those bikers will be Harley-Davidson rider Ron Washum of Fountain Hills who rides with a biker club in Mesa. Washum said the word is definitely out for bikers to gather in Cave Creek. He said there is a great deal of resentment among bikers who believe they have been unfairly portrayed as troublemakers.

Arizona Bike Week, April 5-14, is an official proclamation from the Governor’s Office. The Cave Creek Main Street Rally is not part of statewide Bike Week festivities coordinated by promoter Rich Dillman, who has also been feuding with the Cave Creek faction.

Assistants Attend Exam to Protect Doctor

Women who go for their yearly gynecological exam know the drill.

If their doctor is male, the exam doesn’t begin until a female nurse or medical assistant is present.

But few women know that the assistant is there to protect the doctor, not the patient. And if the patient is abused, the assistant is under no legal obligation to report the incident to police or a medical board.

The only law that comes close deals with minors or vulnerable adults, defined as those with a disability or the elderly.

“Maybe we need one called the Finkel law,” said David Michael Cantor, a medical malpractice attorney in Scottsdale.

He was referring to Brian Finkel, an abortion doctor who was arrested Wednesday and accused of fondling at least nine patients over the past eight years.

Medical assistants were present during the questionable exams and abortions, though it is unclear what they saw. Although they did not come forward on their own, several assistants, when questioned by Phoenix police, said they were uncomfortable that Finkel was touching patient’s breasts during visits.

Unlike registered nurses, licensed practical nurses and certified nursing assistants, medical assistants are not bound by any ethical obligation to report suspected cases of sexual abuse, according to the Arizona Board of Nursing.

But at least one abortion doctor says the medical assistants had an ethical obligation.

“I’m somewhat amazed that they didn’t stand up and protect the patients,” said Dr. Robert Tamis, a 40-year gynecologist in the Valley who also performs abortions.

Tamis, who said medical assistants are always present during gynecological exams, said he doesn’t believe a law is needed.

“How do you legislate morality?” he said.

Arizona Sen. Sue Gerard, who heads the Senate Health Committee, agreed.

“You’re asking an untrained person to make a value judgment,” she said. “It’s one of the issues of where do you draw the line.”

Gerard said the larger issue is one of untrained medical professionals. That issue came up during another recent case involving an abortion doctor where a woman bled to death.

“I’m concerned about the type of people assisting in medical procedures overall,” she said.

Her advice to patients: Ask for the credentials of everyone administering health care.

“I don’t know what the answer is except to be better consumers,” she said.

Click Here for Free ConsultationComparison Questions to Ask when Hiring a Lawyer

Request a Free Consultation

Fill out the form below to receive a free and confidential initial consultation.

Click here for important legal disclaimer.


10.0 Superb Rating AVVO

10.0 Superb Rating

AV-Highest Rated Preeminent Lawyers Martindale-Hubbell

AV-Rated Preeminent Lawyers

Southwest Super Lawyer Family Law

Super Lawyers
Top Family Lawyers

Top 10 Attorney National Academy of Fammily Law Attorneys

Top 10 Attorney
National Academy of
Family Law Attorneys

Top 100 Trial Lawyers American Trial Lawyers Association

Top 100 Trial Lawyers
American Trial Lawyers Association

Sustaining Member Arizona Trial Lawyers Association

Sustaining Member
Arizona Trial Lawyers Association

Top 100 Lawyer American Society of Legal Advocates

Top 100 Lawyer
American Society of Legal Advocates

Charter Member Trial Masters

Charter Member
Trial Masters

Nation's Top 1% Attorney National Association of Distinguished Counsel

Nation's Top 1% Attorney
National Association of Distinguished Counsel

Lifetime Charter Member Best Attorneys of America

Lifetime Charter Member
Best Attorneys of America

Member American Bar Foundation

American Bar Foundation

Member American Association for Justice

American Association for Justice

Member Since 1989 American Bar Association

Member Since 1989
American Bar Association

Top Valley Lawyer North Valley Magazine

Top Valley Lawyer
North Valley Magazine

Better Business Bureau A+ Rating

Better Business Bureau
A+ Rating

Call Now Button